Thursday, April 10, 2008

Comfort in metaphor


Jennifer Graf Groneberg faces a familiar journey in Road Map to Holland: How I found my way through my son's first two years with Down Syndrome. I, too, had to suddenly change my perception, modify my hopes and dreams, and dig for information when my infant son's blindness was diagnosed. Ms. Groneberg and I faced parallels in some of our thinking processes, and one of those was a constant re-interpretation of life metaphors.
The Holland metaphor in her title comes from an essay by Emily Perl Kingsley describing the paradigm shift when a baby is diagnosed with a disability or other life-altering condition. The well-known essay likens the thought process to planning for a vacation to Italy, only to find yourself in Holland instead. The destination is still beautiful, but it's totally different from the original plan.
I've never been a big fan of the Holland essay and metaphor, although I knew at least one mom who posted it on her refrigerator as inspiration. Rather, I likened the challenge to expecting a car with automatic everything and then getting a manual transmission instead. The driver has to learn to shift gears quickly and smoothly, both literally and figuratively.
Groneberg hears and adapts other metaphors to her own experience. "Kids are like sandpaper" didn't quite make sense at first. Did it mean raising kids is rough? Wears you down? Eventually she takes a more positive angle on this one, seeing her child as the sander who smooths out her own rough edges as he grows.
Groneberg's journey with Avery paralleled my journey with Amigo in several ways. I kept nodding as I read, thinking, "Oh, I remember going through that." But I also remembered that the first few years were the easy ones. Babies are babies, even when they're disabled. Her twins' story might be more interesting as they grow up, are forced to face their differences, and the biases toward Avery and his Down syndrome become more overt. Going through the IEP process, making transition plans, looking into job training, and more await the family in the years ahead.

My hope for the Groneberg family is that they will love and cherish all three of their children for themselves, their strengths, and their unique individual traits. Despite the difficulty of the first few years, I hope they can see their glass, however fragile, as half full rather than half empty.

For more discussion of this book and others, go to MotherTalk Book Talks and Salon.

MotherTalk provided me with a free copy of this book in order to read it and review it. If you'd like to read it, leave me a note in the comments that includes your email or a link. I'll mail it out to the first interested commenter.

Labels: , ,

Digg! Stumble It! add to kirtsy

6 Comments:

Blogger Cheryl said...

I feel confident in saying that they do see all of the blessings. Jennifer is a regular contributor at ParentDish, and I love reading her posts about how much joy she finds in her life with her boys. I already have this book since I pre-ordered it from Amazon, and I'm really looking forward to reading it.

4/10/2008 7:01 AM  
OpenID jennifergrafgroneberg said...

Thank you for reviewing my book. You're the first to speak about the Holland metaphor, which I know doesn't work for everyone. I wonder if the difference in diagnoses matters? In any case, parenting is never one-size-fits-all, thanks for bringing this up.

4/10/2008 9:00 AM  
Anonymous Katrina Stonoff said...

The Holland essay worked for me the first time I saw it (soon after my daughter was diagnosed with Down Syndrome), but it's so ubiquitous , especially in the DS community, that it's become a cliché.

It's like that Debby Boone song, "You Light Up My Life." It was a pretty song, but it got SO much airplay that, all these decades later, I'm still sick of it!

4/10/2008 10:00 AM  
Blogger Andrea said...

It's been really interesting reading all of the reviews of Roadmap to Holland and discovering so many wonderful blogs that I've never seen before--including this one. I'd love to read the book, it you haven't given it away already.

4/10/2008 10:17 AM  
Blogger clueless carolinagirl said...

Katrina,

Me Too! Me Too!! I still can't stand "You Light Up My Life". My Gawd, I can't remember another song that received as much airplay--and then I had to hear it at weddings for awhile too.

4/12/2008 12:26 PM  
Blogger Tilly Cat & Pip-Squeak said...

Thanks for this review... I really enjoyed it, (as a long time lurker on DS blogs.)

If noone else wants the book, would you consider sending it to me? We're starting the procedure to adopt a baby with DS in a couple of months and I'd love to read it. I live in the UK but I'll send you the postage!

Anna

4/14/2008 3:23 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Smile!

Search & Win

About 1 in 5 child deaths is due to injury. CDC Vital Signs www.cdc.gov/vitalsigns

Creative 

Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 2.5 License.

Copyright, 2003-2008 by OkayByMe. All rights reserved. No part of this blog may be reproduced in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means, including information storage and retrieval without written permission from Daisy, the publisher, except by a reviewer who may quote brief passages in a review. In other words, stealing is bad, and if you take what doesn't belong to you, it's YOUR karma and my lawyers you might deal with.